Milwaukee First-Degree Intentional Homicide Sentence: Case Outcomes
Wisconsin calls the offense first-degree intentional homicide. This guide keeps that intent separate from second-degree intentional homicide, reckless homicide and felony murder. The selected cases also span different sentencing eras, which makes a single numeric comparison misleading.
Three named records report different life-sentence structures, not three fully qualified comparable city cases. McKnight’s news report uses life-without-parole wording; Pietura’s expressly denies extended-supervision eligibility. Webb’s historical judgment instead sets February 17, 2038 parole eligibility. None is converted into a numerical prison range or promised release date.
Observed Outcomes
| Case | Milwaukee offense location | Final sentence reported | Sentence scope | Sources |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Robert J. McKnight | Parking lot near 24th and Greenfield, Milwaukee | Life without parole in the July 18, 2026 report; exact sentencing day not specified. | Target intentional homicide sentence; retain the source wording rather than infer an additional supervision term. | Sentencing source · Location record |
| David Pietura | Home near 54th and Meinecke, Milwaukee | Life without extended-supervision eligibility; July 26, 2024, after a June first-degree-intentional-homicide plea. | Target homicide sentence. A co-defendant in the same incident is not a second cluster. | Sentencing source |
| Jermaine M. Webb | 2703 West Wisconsin Avenue, City of Milwaukee | Homicide: life with February 17, 2038 parole eligibility. Armed robbery: 40 years concurrent. Affirmed November 12, 1996; 101 days custody credit separately reported. | Historical pre-truth-in-sentencing judgment: the 40-year robbery term is not described as modern initial confinement plus extended supervision. | Sentencing source |
Source and Judgment Histories
McKnight’s July 18, 2026 report identifies the conviction, but does not give the sentencing day. Its separate August 30, 2024 charging report places the incident in a parking lot near 24th/Greenfield. The charging-stage allegations are used for reported location, not as proof of conviction; its weekday/date wording is not independently resolved here.
Pietura’s July 26, 2024 report describes that Friday’s life sentence after a June plea. Child-abuse and corpse-hiding charges were dismissed but read in for sentencing; they are not additional convictions. The report connects the shared house with conduct and last-seen evidence, while Hawley/Vliet is the later discovery point. A co-defendant charged in the same incident is not another completed independent prosecution in that report.
The official November 12, 1996 Webb decision, appeal 96-0490-CR-NM, affirms the homicide and armed-robbery judgment and locates the May 1994 offenses at 2703 West Wisconsin Avenue in the City of Milwaukee. It separates life with February 17, 2038 parole eligibility from the concurrent 40-year robbery term and 101 days custody credit. That eligibility is not guaranteed release, a fixed 40-year homicide sentence or a modern supervision component. The review date is not substituted for an unspecified original sentencing day.
How to Read These Sentences
Pietura’s report expressly describes eligibility for extended supervision. McKnight’s report uses life-without-parole wording. Webb’s older judgment instead gives a future parole-eligibility date. Those descriptions should not be flattened into one release calculation or treated as interchangeable modern supervision terms.
Wisconsin initial confinement and extended supervision are separate components. A total sentence is not automatically a prison term. Older parole-based judgments also require their own terminology rather than a conversion into modern supervision components.
Scope and Limits
The Wisconsin State Law Library elements guide provides legal terminology and warns that its compilation may not be current. Consult the applicable law and judgment for a particular case; this page does not state a statutory sentencing range.
These selected reported outcomes are not all Milwaukee cases, an average, a typical sentence or a prediction. Source-described streets and incident points are not automatically independent municipal-boundary certification. Full city qualification, applicable historical law and complete later-docket review remain open. Prison, supervision, custody credit, fines and restitution are not added together as prison time.
Relevant sentencing, conviction and location passages were read September 28, 2026 UTC (September 29 in Istanbul). Focused official name/court searches were bounded, not exhaustive docket clearance. Matched court results are identified only where stated in this article. No numerical observed range is asserted.
Find currently published guides on the Milwaukee city hub. Review our case-selection methodology and editorial standards for source and sample limitations. This material is general information, not advice about an individual case.